Copincollo
"bioethical issues and educational issues have in common the anthropological question. In both cases, everything depends on the conception of man: a subject of freedom or human-machine that acts according to certain procedures? In the former case the contradiction between the vision of health and disease in purely material terms, and a humanistic vision is usually obvious and clear to everyone. In the second case, the contradiction should be clear: education is a mere application techniques: Teaching and aims to train a person capable of asking questions of meaning? Unfortunately, many who align themselves with conviction at the second point of view, then, when the facts are, adjusting teaching techniques to flatter. In short, the issue of education is manifested a low level of "epistemological vigilance", a poor ability to keep out those Trojans that frustrate even the most ardent intentions.
I think the book "The educational challenge" (Yale University Press, 2009) - important work of the Committee for Cultural Project of the Italian Bishops' Conference - expresses a surprisingly high level of "vigilance epistemological. " This book - which goes on all the issues of educational crisis, family, school, business, labor, consumer, media, etc.. - Focuses on the anthropological issue, identified as the primary educational crisis, the breakdown of the human: the split between intellect and emotions, reducing rationality to the analytical forms induced by a positivist view of science, the widening gap between education and training, depletion of the application sense. And yet - you look - the mere invocation of words such as "sense", "person" and "values" does not apply to exorcise a crisis so profound. We must "return to roots human capacity of education ", or the knowledge that the starting point of education is the coming-to-world and its enigma. Education is a continuation 'of that agenda with the parents first to make the right child of the promise that they have done by putting the world. " Hence the indissoluble relationship between generation and education. Education is "an exercise in humanity" that involves many actors - the individual, family, school, teacher - and it is a covenant between generations. Education needs to "authority" and "tradition" - to be retained, Hannah Arendt said - because only then can provide the right tools to reform the world. The question of meaning arises in the relationship of youth with the authority and tradition, as well as through the acquisition of the "narratives of the great cultural traditions, religious, moral and political, which brought a sense of unity of existence, the world and history, "and postmodern metaphor not in the game," understood as free of happening relieved of responsibility and purpose, "from whom the idea of \u200b\u200bself because" we can not and should not teach about where you are, but only to live in the condition of one who is Direct from anywhere. "
not surprising that from premises so clear and strong condemnation of the resulting model that educational gap and training, "according to the acquisition of knowledge, skills, competencies, consistent with the technological structure of the contemporary world." The courageous criticism of the business model dominated by the encyclopaedist, the procedure and the methodology, can throw to the winds the silly rhyme knowledge / skills / competencies to be too many parroted without understanding that does not express anything but technocratic ideology. Nor surprisingly, the port is a critique of the famous formula of 'learning to learn'. But it is unusual clarity with which it is made. It is noted that the replacement of a disinterested face to know the progress of knowledge with learning, which compares with practical needs and obsession for more sophisticated assessment methods that identify it with a measurement - which, I might add, is also a nonsense Conceptual - leading to a complicity between reason surrenders its search for foundations and technology antoreferenziale. Hence the ideology of education as "knowing how", such as instructions on "how to do." The formula of 'learning to learn' is worse than a mutilation which is the misleading idea that educating does not mean to propose "content, values, world views", in other words culture, but mere job training. It involves deleterious reduction of the teacher to "facilitator", while he serves as far more important "to present, through the various disciplines, symbolic references and patterns of behavior that may be relevant to young people's lives."
These bold assertions make the book a more effective and constructive document that have been produced recently on the issue of education. There is not space here to spread on the analysis of specific contexts. Themes are as vast and complex that it would be too much to claim that the "supervisory epistemological 'is not some failure. So, from time to time, emerge the notorious knowledge / skills / competencies and reappeared jargon didattichese euroburocratico style. It is well known the diligence with which the ideology of Brussels sweeps away even the smallest concession to the mindset of the kind incurred in the book. Precisely for this reason more attention would have been desirable to leave no room for contradictory approaches. Why take the good, the formula of 'education', which is an exemplary application of the reduction 'technical education? It would have been even better not take as gospel some statistics on the condition of education, anch’esse ispirate a metodi assai discutibili.Concludo con una questione di grande importanza: la scienza. Se al libro è sottesa l’idea che l’approccio tecnicistico all’educazione distrugge una visione umanistica, se con tanta chiarezza si critica la mutilazione positivistica della ragione, non si può eludere il problema di come insegnare le scienze. Né è possibile risolverlo dicendo che le scienze sono educative in quanto conducono alla questione della “verità” attraverso l’esame della «corrispondenza delle loro affermazioni con una “realtà” che non dipende da noi». È comprensibile il timore di esporsi all’accusa di una “riapertura del processo a Galileo”, but accept an objectivist realism naive and do not put the problem of techno-science that expresses pure will power and no desire for truth, undermines the power of speech. No education for truth is compatible with the avoidance of the theme of "sense" of what science stands for. Addressing the question of science - from its conceptual to the concrete implications on education (such relations should be established between the teaching of science and philosophy?) - Is a requirement that stems from their thesis proposals in this important book. "
I think the book "The educational challenge" (Yale University Press, 2009) - important work of the Committee for Cultural Project of the Italian Bishops' Conference - expresses a surprisingly high level of "vigilance epistemological. " This book - which goes on all the issues of educational crisis, family, school, business, labor, consumer, media, etc.. - Focuses on the anthropological issue, identified as the primary educational crisis, the breakdown of the human: the split between intellect and emotions, reducing rationality to the analytical forms induced by a positivist view of science, the widening gap between education and training, depletion of the application sense. And yet - you look - the mere invocation of words such as "sense", "person" and "values" does not apply to exorcise a crisis so profound. We must "return to roots human capacity of education ", or the knowledge that the starting point of education is the coming-to-world and its enigma. Education is a continuation 'of that agenda with the parents first to make the right child of the promise that they have done by putting the world. " Hence the indissoluble relationship between generation and education. Education is "an exercise in humanity" that involves many actors - the individual, family, school, teacher - and it is a covenant between generations. Education needs to "authority" and "tradition" - to be retained, Hannah Arendt said - because only then can provide the right tools to reform the world. The question of meaning arises in the relationship of youth with the authority and tradition, as well as through the acquisition of the "narratives of the great cultural traditions, religious, moral and political, which brought a sense of unity of existence, the world and history, "and postmodern metaphor not in the game," understood as free of happening relieved of responsibility and purpose, "from whom the idea of \u200b\u200bself because" we can not and should not teach about where you are, but only to live in the condition of one who is Direct from anywhere. "
not surprising that from premises so clear and strong condemnation of the resulting model that educational gap and training, "according to the acquisition of knowledge, skills, competencies, consistent with the technological structure of the contemporary world." The courageous criticism of the business model dominated by the encyclopaedist, the procedure and the methodology, can throw to the winds the silly rhyme knowledge / skills / competencies to be too many parroted without understanding that does not express anything but technocratic ideology. Nor surprisingly, the port is a critique of the famous formula of 'learning to learn'. But it is unusual clarity with which it is made. It is noted that the replacement of a disinterested face to know the progress of knowledge with learning, which compares with practical needs and obsession for more sophisticated assessment methods that identify it with a measurement - which, I might add, is also a nonsense Conceptual - leading to a complicity between reason surrenders its search for foundations and technology antoreferenziale. Hence the ideology of education as "knowing how", such as instructions on "how to do." The formula of 'learning to learn' is worse than a mutilation which is the misleading idea that educating does not mean to propose "content, values, world views", in other words culture, but mere job training. It involves deleterious reduction of the teacher to "facilitator", while he serves as far more important "to present, through the various disciplines, symbolic references and patterns of behavior that may be relevant to young people's lives."
These bold assertions make the book a more effective and constructive document that have been produced recently on the issue of education. There is not space here to spread on the analysis of specific contexts. Themes are as vast and complex that it would be too much to claim that the "supervisory epistemological 'is not some failure. So, from time to time, emerge the notorious knowledge / skills / competencies and reappeared jargon didattichese euroburocratico style. It is well known the diligence with which the ideology of Brussels sweeps away even the smallest concession to the mindset of the kind incurred in the book. Precisely for this reason more attention would have been desirable to leave no room for contradictory approaches. Why take the good, the formula of 'education', which is an exemplary application of the reduction 'technical education? It would have been even better not take as gospel some statistics on the condition of education, anch’esse ispirate a metodi assai discutibili.Concludo con una questione di grande importanza: la scienza. Se al libro è sottesa l’idea che l’approccio tecnicistico all’educazione distrugge una visione umanistica, se con tanta chiarezza si critica la mutilazione positivistica della ragione, non si può eludere il problema di come insegnare le scienze. Né è possibile risolverlo dicendo che le scienze sono educative in quanto conducono alla questione della “verità” attraverso l’esame della «corrispondenza delle loro affermazioni con una “realtà” che non dipende da noi». È comprensibile il timore di esporsi all’accusa di una “riapertura del processo a Galileo”, but accept an objectivist realism naive and do not put the problem of techno-science that expresses pure will power and no desire for truth, undermines the power of speech. No education for truth is compatible with the avoidance of the theme of "sense" of what science stands for. Addressing the question of science - from its conceptual to the concrete implications on education (such relations should be established between the teaching of science and philosophy?) - Is a requirement that stems from their thesis proposals in this important book. "